Commissioned Memory

EN HU
Header image

1965 | Victims

Resistance
Antifascist memory politics embedded the Holocaust in a rather broad historical narrative, shifting the emphasis from the portrayal of victimhood, which was considered “pessimistic,” to resistance. The plans for the 1965 exhibition were criticized by the director of the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum precisely because he considered the considerable weight of the 1919–39 period disproportionate to that of the deportations in 1944.

Nevertheless, the figures and perspectives of the victims are included in the exhibits. The prisoners of the concentration camp in Gyula Konfár’s monumental painting no longer resemble protesting workers raising their fists to the sky, as in Makrisz Agamemnon’s Hungarian monument in Mauthausen (1959–64). Yet mere victimhood was not considered satisfactory: the crossed arms of the figures therefore affirm the contemporary title, Resistance in the Camp.

Metamorphoses
Two sculptures were included in the 1965 exhibition, by István Martsa and József Somogyi, both shown here in photographs. Martsa was commissioned to execute a composition, created for the invitation-only competition of the memorial in Mauthausen, which the artist had intended to turn into a memorial statue of Miklós Radnóti a year earlier. The figure stepping on the pyre suggests a voluntary martyrdom, his arms are intersected in the form of a cross.

A bronze cast of József Somogyi’s 1963 plaster model was commissioned for the Auschwitz exhibition, later a second copy was also made for the Budapest Municipal Gallery, entitled Mourner. From Auschwitz, the sculpture was transferred to the Labor Movement Museum in 1979, and long after the latter’s dissolution, it was transferred to the Hungarian National Gallery, losing all its data and context, as a work entitled Ballad, dated around 1960. The title can actually be considered apt in view of the figure, resembling a peasant woman.

However, similarly to its afterlife, the work’s prehistory was not without unexpected twists and turns either: originally, Somogyi’s work had nothing to do with either the Holocaust or Auschwitz. The first version of the work, which differed only in a few details, was created in 1955 for a competition for the memorial to the martyrs of the labor movement.

Forced March
Tibor Barabás’s sculpture entitled Forced March (1959) is a reference to the poem of the same title written by a victim of the Holocaust, Miklós Radnóti, while he was in forced labor service. The Jewish Museum, which had previously included the work in its Holocaust exhibition From Slavery to Freedom (1960), proposed the work for the exhibition in Auschwitz. The jury of the Lectorate, the commissioning body for the works, however, replied laconically that they “did not consider the work suitable.” It was certainly not primarily for aesthetic reasons, but for ideological ones: the two figures are characterized by the same “pessimism” condemned in the Mauthausen competition: they lack both resistance and martyrdom stylized as a voluntary act.

Roma Holocaust
The Roma Holocaust was completely absent from the Auschwitz exhibitions of the 1960s. To compensate for this, the earliest Hungarian artwork, the memorial design by György Jovánovics (1974), and an interview with the artist are on display on the opposite wall. József Lakatos’s short film Forgotten Dead (1981), the earliest artistic interpretation by a Roma artist, will be shown as an accompanying program to the exhibition. The first work of art by a Roma artist that partly depicts the Holocaust, Tamás Péli’s monumental painting Birth (1983), was shown to the public in 2021 at the OFF-Biennale in the Budapest History Museum.

Interview with György Jovánovics about his Plans for a Roma Holocaust Memorial (1974)
interviewer: Daniel Véri
cameraman: Péter Szalay
editing and subtitling: Darius Krolikowski
photo (portrait): Balázs Deim
photo (works): Miklós Sulyok
Budapest, 2019